![]()
by
Tony Prescott
Politics, Law & Society
Opinions
October 21, 2016
For a sci-fi fan like me, fascinated by the nature of human intelligence and the possibility of building life-like robots, it’s always interesting to find a new angle on these questions. As a re-imagining of the original 1970s science fiction film set in a cowboy-themed, hyper-real adult theme park populated by robots that look and act like people, Westworld does not disappoint.
Westworld challenges us to consider the difference between being human and being a robot. From the beginning of this new serialisation on HBO we are confronted with scenes of graphic human-on-robot violence. But the robots in Westworld have more than just human-like physical bodies, they display emotion including extreme pain, they see and recognise each other’s suffering, they bleed and even die. What makes this acceptable, at least within Westworld’s narrative, is that they are just extremely life-like human simulations; while their behaviour is realistically automated, there is “nobody home”.
But from the start, this notion that a machine of such complexity is still merely a machine is undermined by constant reminders that they are also so much like us. The disturbing message, echoing that of previous sci-fi classics such as Blade Runner and AI, is that machines could one day be so close to human as to be indistinguishable – not just in intellect and appearance, but also in moral terms.
At the same time, by presenting an alternate view of the human condition through the technological mirror of life-like robots, Westworld causes us to reflect that we are perhaps also just sophisticated machines, albeit of a biological kind – an idea that has been forcefully argued by the philosopher Daniel Dennett.
The unfortunate robots in Westworld have, at least initially, no insight into their existential plight. They enter into each new day programmed with enthusiasm and hope, oblivious to its pre-scripted violence and tragedy. We may pity these automatons their fate – but how closely does this blinkered ignorance, belief in convenient fictions, and misguided presumption of agency resemble our own human predicament?
Westworld arrives at a time when people are already worried about the real-world impact of advances in robotics and artificial intelligence. Physicist Stephen Hawking and technologist Elon Musk are among the powerful and respected voices to have expressed concern about allowing the AI genie to escape the bottle. Westworld’s contribution to the expanding canon of science fiction dystopias will do nothing to quell such fears. Channelling Shakespeare’s King Lear, a malfunctioning robot warns us in chilling terms: “I shall have such revenges on you both. The things I will do, what they are, yet I know not. But they will be the terrors of the Earth.”
But against these voices are other distinguished experts trying to quell the panic. For Noam Chomsky, the intellectual godfather of modern AI, all talk of matching human intelligence in the foreseeable future remains fiction, not science. One of the world’s best-known roboticists, Rodney Brooks has called on us to relax: AI is just a tool, not a threat.
As a neuroscientist and roboticist, I agree that we are far from being able to replicate human intelligence in robot form. Our current systems are too simple, probably by several orders of magnitude. Building human-level AI is extremely hard; as Brooks says, we are just at the beginning of a very long road. But I see the path along which we are developing AI as one of symbiosis, in which we can use robots to benefit society and exploit advances in artificial intelligence to boost our own biological intelligence.
Nevertheless, in recent years the robots and AI are “just tools” line of argument has begun to frustrate me. Partly because it has failed to calm the disquiet around AI, and partly because there are good reasons why these technologies are different from others in the past.
Even if robots are just tools, people will see them as more than that. It seems natural for people to respond to robots – even some of the more simple, non-human robots we have today – as though they have goals and intentions. It may be an innate tendency of our profoundly social human minds to see entities that act intelligently in this way. More importantly, people may see robots as having psychological properties such as the ability to experience suffering.
It may be difficult to persuade them to see otherwise, particularly if we continue to make robots more life-like. If so, we may have to adapt our ethical frameworks to take this into account. For instance, we might consider violence towards a robot as wrong, even though the suffering is imagined rather than real. Indeed, faced with violence towards a robot some people show this sort of ethical response spontaneously. We will have to deal with these issues as we learn to live with robots.
As AI and robot technology becomes more complex, robots may come to have interesting psychological properties that make them more than just tools. The fictional robots of Westworld are clearly in this category, but already real robots are being developed that have artificial drives and motivations, that are aware of their own bodies as distinct from the rest of the world, that are equipped with internal models of themselves and others as social entities, and that are able to think about their own past and future.
These are not properties that we find in drills and screwdrivers. They are embryonic psychological capacities that, so far, have only been found in living, sentient entities such as humans and animals. Stories such as Westworld remind us that as we progress toward ever more sophisticated AI, we should consider that this path might lead us both to machines that are more like us, and to seeing ourselves as more like machines.
This article was originally posted on The Conversation
If you enjoyed this article, you might also be interested in:
The new Westworld: Humanizing the un-human, or dehumanizing humankind?
Ex Machina: When Turing meets Bechdel test
President Obama discusses artificial intelligence with Media Lab Director Joi Ito
See all the latest robotics news on Robohub, or sign up for our weekly newsletter.
Tony Prescott is a Professor of Cognitive Neuroscience at the University of Sheffield and Director of Sheffield Robotics, a cross-disciplinary collaborative enterprise involving both Universities in Sheffield..... read more
Artificial Intelligence machine learning opinion science fiction Singularity Social aspect Westworld
Research & Innovation
Business & Finance
Health & Medicine
Politics, Law & Society
Arts & Entertainment
Education & DIY
Events
Military & Defense
Exploration & Mining
Mapping & Surveillance
Enviro. & Agriculture
Aerial
Automotive
Industrial Automation
Consumer & Household
Space
latest posts popular reported elsewhere
Swarms of precision agriculture robots could help put food on the table
by
Vito Trianni, Joris IJsselmuiden, Ramon Haken
Prepping a robot for its journey to Mars
by
MIT News
Introducing H-ROS: the Hardware Robot Operating System
by
Víctor Mayoral Vilches
Schiaparelli, are you there? The high risks of space robotics again crash home
by
Alex Kirkpatrick
RoboBusiness 2016: Our takeaways
by
Samuel Bouchard, Robotiq Inc.
Who are the most active robotics investors?
by
Andra Keay, Silicon Valley Robotics
Cinema meets robots at the Robotic Online Short Film Festival
by
Ricardo Dominguez Jover
Automation should complement professional expertise, not replace it
by
Frank Pasquale
Why DJI is succeeding in making and selling drones and 3DR didn’t
by
Frank Tobe
Professor Emeritus Whitman Richards dies at 84
by
CSAIL MIT
latest posts popular reported elsewhere
The new Westworld: Humanizing the un-human, or dehumanizing humankind?Introducing H-ROS: the Hardware Robot Operating SystemWhite House releases reports focusing on opportunities and challenges of AIWhy DJI is succeeding in making and selling drones and 3DR didn’t25 women in robotics you need to know about – 2016Meet RoboGabby: She’s on a mission to teach more girls about roboticsPresident Obama discusses artificial intelligence with Media Lab Director Joi ItoThe evolution of assembly lines: A brief historyIt’s not only engineers who work in roboticsHow do self-driving cars work?
latest posts popular reported elsewhere
Schiaparelli: Mars probe ‘crash site identified’ | BBC News
Tesla Will Make Its Cars Fully Self-Driving, but Not Turn the System On Yet | New York Times
Sam Harris: Can we build AI without losing control over it? | TED
NREC 20th Anniversary: Dr. Daniel L. Schmoldt, National Program Leader, NIFA/USDA | CMU Robotics
Robot mussels help measure the effects of climate change | Engadget
Paralysed man with implant feels touch | Nature
Deep Driving: A revolutionary AI technique is about to transform the self-driving car | MIT Technology Review
How much heat does the ocean trap? Robots find out | Scientific American
Korea, US to develop disaster-response robot tech | The Korea Herald
Royal Navy to explore artificial intelligence use in battle threat assessment | Computer Business Review
Give a 3D printer artificial intelligence, and this is what you’ll get | Yahoo Tech
Meet Big-i, world’s first personalized family robot to help you around the home | The TechNews
Anki’s Cozmo robot is the new, adorable face of artificial intelligence | The Verge
All eyes on the red planet as ESA’s lander prepares to hurtle towards Mars | The Guardian
SA robotics firm takes on NASA Mars challenge | ITWeb
Market grows for ‘regtech’, or AI for regulation | Financial Times
This robot can do more push-ups because it sweats | IEEE Spectrum
The blind have high hopes for self-driving cars | MIT Technology Review
Will jobs exist in 2050? | The Guardian
AVC 2016: Classic Autonomous Vehicle Competition | SparkFun Electronics
EU Robotics Week
February 8, 2013
A dedicated jobs board for the global robotics community.
Sr. Machine Vision / SLAM Engineer - Mayfield RoboticsRobotic Engineering Leader - ConfidentialTechnical Lead (Robotics Software Development) - Advanced Remanufacturing and Technology CentreSenior – Principal Development Scientist (Robotics Development) - Advanced Remanufacturing and Technology CentreDevelopment Engineer – Senior (Robotic Software Development) - Advanced Remanufacturing and Technology Center
